Kinship Guard

Kinship Guard › Guides

Power of attorney or guardianship for an aging parent: which one applies to your family

Updated 10 November 2026 · 7 min read

The difference comes down to one question: can your parent still understand and sign a document today? If yes, a power of attorney is the route. Your parent chooses who will act for them, signs it, and nobody goes to court. If no, a power of attorney is no longer possible, and the family has to ask a court or tribunal to appoint someone, which is guardianship (in the US often called conservatorship for money; in England and Wales, deputyship). Guardianship is slower, more expensive, and decided by a stranger, so the practical answer for most families is: if your parent can still sign, talk about a power of attorney this month.

This page explains the difference, gives a decision rule for your situation, shows what each route is called and costs in five places, and ends with a checklist for this week. It is general information, not legal advice. The rules differ by country and state.

The difference in one table

Power of attorneyGuardianship (or deputyship)
Who chooses the decision-makerYour parentA court or tribunal
When it is madeWhile your parent can still decideAfter they can no longer decide
What it coversWhat the document says, and no moreWhat the order says
CostLow (a form, sometimes a lawyer, sometimes a registration fee)Higher (application fees, sometimes a hearing, sometimes yearly supervision)
Who checks the decision-makerUsually nobody, unless someone complainsThe court or a public body, often every year
Your parent's own sayThey set the termsDecided for them, though their wishes must be considered

Two points the table hides. First, a power of attorney can only be signed by someone who has capacity at the time of signing: GOV.UK says you must be 18 or over and have mental capacity when you make a lasting power of attorney, and Western Australia's guidance says the same for an enduring power of attorney (GOV.UK; WA Government). Second, guardianship is meant to be the last resort. Western Australia's Office of the Public Advocate says the State Administrative Tribunal appoints a guardian "only when there is no other appropriate way" of meeting the person's needs that would be less restrictive (OPA WA). In the US, the Administration for Community Living says state laws generally allow guardianship only as a last resort and require less restrictive alternatives to be considered (ACL).

Money and health are usually separate documents

The most common surprise: the power of attorney the family has covers money, but the decision in front of them is about care.

  • US: the NIA lists a durable power of attorney for finances and, separately, a durable power of attorney for health care, which names a health care proxy (NIA).
  • England and Wales: there are two lasting powers of attorney, one for property and financial affairs and one for health and welfare. Your parent can make one or both (GOV.UK).
  • Western Australia: an enduring power of attorney covers financial and property decisions and "does not give an attorney the authority to make personal and lifestyle decisions" or medical treatment decisions. Those need an enduring power of guardianship (WA Government; OPA WA).
  • New South Wales: an enduring power of attorney covers money; an enduring guardian makes health and lifestyle decisions (NSW Government).
  • Victoria: one enduring power of attorney can cover personal matters, financial matters, or both, but it does not cover medical treatment. That is the role of a medical treatment decision maker (OPA Victoria).

So a family with only a financial power can still end up needing a guardian for a care decision, if there is a dispute and no less restrictive way to settle it.

Which route applies to you: a decision rule

Work down the list and stop at the first line that fits.

  1. Your parent can understand and sign, and nothing is in place. Make the powers now: one for money, one for health and care (or one document that covers both, where your state allows). This is the cheapest and least intrusive route, and your parent chooses the people.
  2. Your parent can sign, and a power exists, but it covers only money. Add the health and care power while they still can.
  3. You are not sure whether your parent can still understand it. Ask their doctor before anyone signs. A document signed without capacity can be challenged later; Western Australia's guidance warns that the tribunal could find such a power was not properly made (WA Government).
  4. Your parent can no longer decide, and the right powers exist. Use them. Find the original, check when it starts (some start only once incapacity is confirmed) and, in England and Wales, check it is registered.
  5. Your parent can no longer decide, and there is no power, or not the right one. Check first whether something less formal will do: in the US, ACL lists a Social Security representative payee (the Social Security Administration appoints someone to receive your parent's benefits for them) and, for health decisions, a default health care surrogate under state law, often a spouse or adult child (ACL). If not, apply to the court or tribunal for guardianship or deputyship.
  6. Someone is misusing a power, or the family cannot agree. Ask the oversight body to review it (see the FAQ below).

What it is called, and what it costs, in five places

Figures read on the official pages on 10 November 2026. Where a page gives no fee, the table says so.

PlaceYour parent signs (power of attorney)If they cannot (court or tribunal)
USDurable power of attorney for finances; durable power of attorney for health care. Forms and rules vary by state (NIA)Guardianship or conservatorship through a state court; can be limited or full (ACL). Fees vary by county
England and WalesLasting power of attorney, two types. £92 to register; 8 to 10 weeks if there are no mistakes. The financial one can be used once registered (GOV.UK)Deputy appointed by the Court of Protection. £432 application, £266 if a hearing is needed, £100 assessment for a new deputy, then £320 a year (general supervision) or £35 (minimal) (GOV.UK)
Western AustraliaEnduring power of attorney (money) and enduring power of guardianship (lifestyle and treatment). No cost to make either; no registration (WA Government)Guardian or administrator appointed by the State Administrative Tribunal; a family member or close friend can be appointed (OPA WA)
New South WalesEnduring power of attorney (money) and enduring guardian (health and lifestyle)Guardianship order from the NCAT Guardianship Division, normally for up to 1 year (NSW Government)
VictoriaEnduring power of attorney (personal and/or financial) plus a medical treatment decision maker (OPA Victoria)Guardian or administrator appointed by VCAT; urgent short orders possible where there is immediate risk (VCAT)

A worked comparison for England and Wales, using those fees: both lasting powers of attorney cost £184 to register. A property and affairs deputyship with general supervision costs £432 + £100 + £320 = £852 in the first year without a hearing, and £320 a year after that, before any solicitor's fees. A lasting power of attorney is valid only in England and Wales; Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own arrangements (GOV.UK).

A checklist for this week

  • Find out what already exists. Ask your parent, and look in their papers, for any power of attorney, health care proxy, guardianship document or advance directive.
  • For each one, write down: the type, who is named, whether there are replacements, when it starts, and where the original is.
  • Check whether money and health are both covered. If one is missing, that is the gap to close.
  • If your parent can still decide, book a time to talk about it. The guide to talking to a parent about needing help has lines for starting.
  • Get your state's official form or kit (the WA kits are free from the Office of the Public Advocate) or book a lawyer, and ask the fee first.
  • If you doubt your parent's capacity, ask their doctor before anything is signed.
  • Tell your brothers and sisters what exists and who is named, so nobody learns it at the hospital.
  • Put copies where the family can reach them. The care documents checklist covers what else to keep with them.

Kinship Guard has a shared document vault where a scan of each signed power can sit next to a note of who is named and what it covers. It does not make anything legally valid, and banks and hospitals will still ask for the original or a certified copy. It is optional; a labelled folder that everyone knows about does the same job.

When this page does not apply

If your parent is in danger now, or you suspect someone is taking their money or harming them, do not wait for paperwork: call your local emergency number or the abuse lines on the talking to a parent page. For anything about a specific document, a dispute between family members, or a parent in Scotland, Northern Ireland, another Australian state, Canada or elsewhere, ask a lawyer, the public guardian or public advocate in your parent's state, or in the US the Eldercare Locator on 1-800-677-1116 (NIA). If you are not yet sure your parent needs help at all, start with the signs an aging parent needs more help.

Share the work with your care circle

Kinship Guard keeps scans of the signed documents in a shared vault, so whoever is at the hospital or the bank can see who holds which power without phoning round.

Free to download · iPhone, iPad and Android

Questions

Can I get power of attorney for a parent who already has dementia?

Only if your parent can still understand what they are signing. A diagnosis on its own does not settle that: in England and Wales the Mental Capacity Act 2005 judges capacity for a particular decision at the time it is made, and says a lack of capacity cannot be established merely by reference to a person's condition. Other places work in a similar way. The person witnessing the document, or a lawyer, may ask for a doctor's opinion. If your parent can no longer understand it, a power of attorney is not available and the court or tribunal route is the one that applies.

Does a power of attorney let me decide where my parent lives?

It depends on the type. A financial power of attorney covers money and property only. Where your parent lives, the care they receive and medical treatment need a health, welfare or personal power, which has a different name in each place: a health care proxy in much of the US, a health and welfare LPA in England and Wales, an enduring power of guardianship in Western Australia, an enduring guardian in New South Wales.

We have a power of attorney but my brother disagrees with how it is being used. What now?

Talk first, with the documents on the table, and keep notes. If that fails, the body that oversees these powers can review it: in England and Wales the Office of the Public Guardian, in New South Wales the NCAT Guardianship Division, in Victoria VCAT, in Western Australia the State Administrative Tribunal, in the US the probate or guardianship court in your parent's county.

Is guardianship permanent?

Often not. NSW appoints guardians for a set time, normally up to one year and up to three in special circumstances. US courts can make limited guardianships that cover only some decisions or only a period. Orders can be reviewed, changed or ended.

Sources

  1. Make, register or end a lasting power of attorney · GOV.UK, read 10 November 2026
  2. Register a lasting power of attorney · GOV.UK, read 10 November 2026
  3. Deputies: make decisions for someone who lacks capacity · GOV.UK, read 10 November 2026
  4. Deputy fees · GOV.UK, read 10 November 2026
  5. Enduring Power of Attorney · Government of Western Australia, last updated 10 February 2026
  6. Enduring Power of Guardianship · Office of the Public Advocate, Western Australia, last updated 10 February 2026
  7. Guardianship · Office of the Public Advocate, Western Australia, last updated 30 May 2025
  8. About guardianship orders · NSW Government, read 10 November 2026
  9. Making an enduring power of attorney · Office of the Public Advocate, Victoria, read 10 November 2026
  10. Medical treatment decision makers · Office of the Public Advocate, Victoria, read 10 November 2026
  11. Powers of attorney · VCAT, read 10 November 2026
  12. Mental Capacity Act 2005, section 2 · legislation.gov.uk, The National Archives (UK), read 10 November 2026
  13. Getting Your Affairs in Order Checklist · National Institute on Aging, NIH, content reviewed 1 February 2023
  14. Alternatives to Guardianship · Administration for Community Living, US Department of Health and Human Services, last modified 12 February 2025

Facts about health, law and services in this guide are paraphrased from these pages, read on 10 November 2026. Where a source describes one country's rules, check your own country's official service.

This guide is general information. It is not medical, legal or financial advice. Rules and services differ by country and state, so check with a qualified professional about your situation.

Related guides