Kinship Guard

Kinship Guard › Guides

In-home care vs assisted living for a parent: what each covers, what each costs, and a rule for choosing

Updated 17 November 2026 · 8 min read

In-home care means paid carers come to your parent's own home for set hours. Assisted living means your parent moves to an apartment or room in a building where staff are on site around the clock and meals are provided. Choose by hours. If your parent needs help at set times of day, care at home usually costs less and changes less. If they need someone near at any hour, or more than about 40 paid hours a week, assisted living usually costs less than buying those hours one by one. The working for that figure is below.

This page gives a rule for choosing, the costs with their sources for the United States, Australia and England, and a worksheet to fill in before the family meets. It is general information about services and prices, not advice about your parent's health or money.

What each one covers

The US National Institute on Aging (NIA) describes assisted living as being for people who need help with daily care, but not as much as a nursing home provides. Residents usually have their own apartment or room, share common areas, and get up to three meals a day, help with personal care and medications, housekeeping, laundry, 24-hour supervision and on-site staff, and social activities (NIA).

In-home care is the same kind of help brought to the house. The NHS says it can be as little as an hour a week, several hours a day, or overnight, and that a live-in carer is also possible (NHS homecare).

In-home careAssisted living
Where your parent livesTheir own homeAn apartment or room in a staffed building
When help is thereOnly during the booked hoursStaff on site 24 hours
Meals and housekeepingBooked as extra hours, or done by familyUsually part of the monthly fee
CompanyThe carer, family and neighboursOther residents and organised activities
Housing costsRent or upkeep, food and bills continueUsually inside the fee
What the family still doesRosters, cover when a carer is sick, the gaps between visitsVisits, speaking up for your parent, paperwork
If needs growAdd hours; cost rises with each hourMove up a care level and pay more, the NIA says; may later mean a nursing home

Neither is a nursing home. If your parent needs nursing care through the day and night, the comparison on this page is the wrong one; see "When this page does not apply" below.

The name changes by country

"Assisted living" is mainly a US term. In England the NHS uses "extra care housing" (also called assisted living): a self-contained flat with services from on-site staff, usually available to rent or buy (NHS housing options). In Australia there is no government-subsidised program called assisted living. The subsidised choices are Support at Home, which is care in your own home, and an aged care home. Retirement villages that sell services are private arrangements, and we have not found an official national price for them.

A rule for choosing

Work down the list and stop at the first line that is true.

  1. Your parent is unsafe alone at night, or has wandered or been lost. Booked visits leave gaps. Look at assisted living with a dementia program or live-in care, and ask their doctor first what level of care fits.
  2. Your parent needs more than about 40 hours of paid help a week. Price both. In the US figures below, this is the point where assisted living becomes the cheaper of the two.
  3. Your parent is alone most of the day and has stopped going out. A carer visit gives an hour of company. Assisted living gives neighbours and a dining room. Ask your parent which they would choose.
  4. The family is covering the gaps and one person is worn out. Count that person's unpaid hours as hours. If paid hours plus unpaid hours pass 40 a week, treat it as line 2. Our guide to respite care covers a break in the meantime.
  5. Your parent needs help at set times (mornings, meals, a shower, medication prompts) and wants to stay. Start with in-home care and review it every three months.

Your parent's own wish is part of every line. Our guide on how to talk to a parent about needing help covers that conversation.

What it costs: United States, with the working

The CareScout Cost of Care Survey for 2025, carried out from July to November 2025, gives these national medians: $35 an hour for a non-medical caregiver at home, and $6,200 a month for an assisted living community (CareScout). Prices in your state will differ; the survey page lets you look up your area.

Paid help at homeWorkingPer month
20 hours a week20 × $35 × 52 ÷ 12$3,033
41 hours a week41 × $35 × 52 ÷ 12$6,218
44 hours a week (the survey's own full-time assumption)44 × $35 × 52 ÷ 12$6,673
Around the clock, 168 hours168 × $35 × 52 ÷ 12$25,480
Assisted living communitynational median$6,200

So the two cost the same at about 41 hours a week ($6,200 × 12 ÷ 52 ÷ $35 = 40.9). The home figures do not include rent or mortgage, food, bills and repairs, which continue at home and are usually inside the assisted living fee. That moves the real break-even lower. Add your parent's actual housing costs to the home column before you compare.

Who pays: the NIA says Medicare does not pay for assisted living, most people pay the full cost themselves, Medicaid may cover some aspects depending on the state, and some long-term care insurance covers part.

What it costs: Australia

At home (Support at Home). After an aged care assessment your parent gets one of eight funding classifications, from $2,757.89 to $20,073.50 a quarter (current at 1 October 2026). Clinical supports such as nursing cost them nothing, and from 1 October 2026 the government fully funds personal care such as help with showering. A full pensioner pays 5% of the price of independence services and 17.5% of everyday living services such as cleaning; a self-funded retiree without a Commonwealth Seniors Health Card pays 50% and 80% (My Aged Care). Providers set their own prices and must publish them. As an example only, if a provider charges $95 an hour for cleaning, two hours a week for a 13-week quarter is $2,470, and the contribution is $432.25 for a full pensioner or $1,976 at the 80% rate.

In an aged care home. Everyone pays the basic daily fee, at most $68.93 a day, which is $2,067.90 for 30 days. Depending on a means assessment, a resident may also pay a hotelling contribution of up to $22.15 a day and a non-clinical care contribution of up to $109.45 a day, plus an agreed room price. The government pays the full accommodation cost for people with income below $36,454.60 and assets below $66,500 (My Aged Care). These amounts are indexed in March and September. Use the two My Aged Care fee estimators for your parent's own figures, and call 1800 200 422 to ask for an assessment.

What it costs: England

The NHS gives a typical homecare rate of around £20 an hour, and its homecare page gives a range of £15 to £30. Two hours a day is 14 hours a week: £280 at £20, or between £210 and £420 across the range. If your parent has savings above £23,250, the council will not help with the cost. The value of their home counts only if they are moving into a care home, not for care in their own home (NHS self-funding). The NHS pages give no typical price for extra care housing or care homes, so we give none; ask each scheme for its weekly charge and what it includes. Start by asking the council for a care needs assessment, which is free. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have their own rules.

A worksheet for the family meeting

Fill this in for one ordinary week before anyone argues for an option. Print the page and write on it.

  • Hours a week your parent needs someone with them, and at which times of day
  • Nights in the last month when someone was needed
  • Hours a week each family member gives now, by name
  • Which of those hours each person can keep giving for the next year
  • Paid hours needed after that (total hours minus family hours)
  • Local hourly price for home care × paid hours × 52 ÷ 12 = cost per month
  • Monthly housing costs at home: rent or upkeep, food, bills
  • Monthly fee at two assisted living or extra care places, and what each fee leaves out
  • What your parent says they want, in their own words
  • Who holds power of attorney if a contract must be signed (see power of attorney vs guardianship)
  • The date you will review the decision

If the hours are hard to count, the signs a parent needs more help guide and a shared caregiver task list show what the week really holds.

When this page does not apply

If your parent needs nursing care day and night, ask their doctor or assessor about a nursing home or aged care home instead. If they are in hospital now, ask the discharge planner or social worker what care is being arranged before they come home. If the question is urgent because someone is unsafe today, call your local emergency number. For an assessment of what your parent is entitled to, contact My Aged Care (1800 200 422) in Australia, the Eldercare Locator (800-677-1116) for your Area Agency on Aging in the US, or your council's adult social care team in the UK. A decision about selling a home needs independent financial advice.

Counting the hours as a family

Kinship Guard is an app where a care circle shares tasks, medication confirmations and a journal, so the hours on the worksheet come from a record instead of memory. It does not find, compare or pay for care, and the worksheet works on paper.

Share the work with your care circle

Kinship Guard keeps a parent's tasks, medication confirmations and care journal in one place, so the family can see how many hours of help the week really takes before choosing between care at home and a move.

Free to download · iPhone, iPad and Android

Questions

Is in-home care cheaper than assisted living?

It depends on the hours. In the CareScout 2025 Cost of Care Survey the US national median was $35 an hour for a non-medical caregiver and $6,200 a month for an assisted living community, so paid care at home costs less up to about 41 hours a week and more above that. Rent, food and bills at home come on top; in assisted living housing and meals are usually part of the fee.

Does Medicare pay for assisted living?

No. The US National Institute on Aging says Medicare does not pay for assisted living, most people pay the full cost themselves, Medicaid may cover some aspects depending on the state, and some long-term care insurance policies cover part.

What is assisted living called in Australia and the UK?

In England the NHS calls it extra care housing, or assisted living: a self-contained flat with services from on-site staff, usually to rent or buy. Australia has no government-subsidised program by that name; the subsidised choices are Support at Home in your own home or an aged care home.

Can we try one option before deciding?

Often, yes. A short respite stay in a care home or aged care home, or a few weeks of paid visits at home, shows how your parent finds it before anything is sold or signed. Ask the provider what notice you must give to stop.

Sources

  1. Long-Term Care Facilities: Assisted Living, Nursing Homes, and Other Residential Care · National Institute on Aging, content reviewed 12 October 2023
  2. Cost of Care Survey 2025 · CareScout, read 17 November 2026
  3. Support at Home costs and contributions · My Aged Care, Australian Government, read 17 November 2026
  4. Aged care home costs and fees · My Aged Care, Australian Government, read 17 November 2026
  5. Paying for your own care (self-funding) · NHS, page last reviewed 17 April 2026
  6. Homecare · NHS, page last reviewed 18 January 2024
  7. Moving to a new home: housing options · NHS, page last reviewed 23 May 2024

Facts about health, law and services in this guide are paraphrased from these pages, read on 17 November 2026. Where a source describes one country's rules, check your own country's official service.

This guide is general information. It is not medical, legal or financial advice. Rules and services differ by country and state, so check with a qualified professional about your situation.

Related guides